DON'T LET ONE ACCIDENT COST YOU!
GET CAR INSURANCE WITH ACCIDENT FORGIVENESS TO PROTECT YOUR RATES
Car 
Motorcycle 
Commercial
Roadside Assistance
Other
Accident Forgiveness Auto Insurance
WHAT IS ACCIDENT FORGIVENESS?
Car insurance with accident forgiveness is an add-on that helps protect your premium after your first at-fault accident. It ensures your driving history stays intact, so you won't face penalties for a single mistake. This coverage provides peace of mind, knowing that one accident won't cause your insurance to increase. It's an excellent option for cautious drivers, offering a safety net and allowing them to maintain their coverage without worrying about the financial impact of an accident.
WHO NEEDS CAR INSURANCE WITH ACCIDENT FORGIVENESS?
New or Inexperienced Drivers
Drivers who are new to the road or have limited driving experience may benefit from accidental forgiveness, as it can help prevent a premium increase after their first at-fault accident.
Drivers with Clean Records
Individuals with a history of safe driving and no prior accidents may opt for accidental forgiveness to protect their clean record in the event of a minor future accident.
Young Drivers
Teenagers or young drivers with less experience are more prone to accidents, so accidental forgiveness can help them avoid significant rate hikes after their first mistake.
High-Risk Drivers
Drivers who may already have a higher risk profile, such as those living in areas with high accident rates or owning higher-performance vehicles, may choose accidental forgiveness as a safety net.
Drivers with One-Time Mistakes
Those who have been driving safely for many years but occasionally experience a lapse in judgment or a minor accident may want to consider accidental forgiveness to maintain their low premiums.
WHY DO I NEED ACCIDENT FORGIVENESS AUTO INSURANCE?
Accident forgiveness lets you move forward after your first at-fault accident without affecting your driving record, helping you maintain a steady path ahead.
It helps reduce financial stress, ensuring that one mistake does not lead to higher insurance costs, especially for drivers with a previously clean record.
Opting for accident forgiveness can be a perk. It protects against sudden price hikes and rewards safe drivers with financial flexibility and stable insurance rates.
Many insurers incentivize this add-on, encouraging more responsible driving and allowing policyholders to maintain lower rates despite an occasional driving mistake.
This coverage is mainly for new drivers, offering them peace of mind while they gain experience on the road without fear of financial consequences or premium increases.
WHAT IS THE COST OF CAR INSURANCE FOR ACCIDENT FORGIVENESS?
The cost of car insurance can increase significantly if you are found at fault in an accident. To help mitigate this, many insurers offer accident forgiveness, an optional add-on that prevents your premium from rising after your first at-fault accident. This coverage typically costs between $15-$60, but the price can vary based on several factors. While this add-on is not legally required, it provides financial protection. Various factors determine the extent of the increase, such as:
Insurance Provider
Driving History
Accident Frequency
Coverage Level
Age of the Driver
Vehicle Type
State Regulations
Claims History
Deductible Amount
Policy Type
Location
Driving Experience
Premium Payment Frequency
HOW MUCH DOES INSURANCE GO UP AFTER AN ACCIDENT?
The table compares the average annual premiums for full coverage and minimum coverage before and after an at-fault accident. Before an accident, the average full-coverage premium is $2,671, while the minimum-coverage premium is $806. After an at-fault accident, the premium for full coverage increases to $3,841, marking a 44% increase, and the premium for minimum coverage rises to $1,175, reflecting a 46% increase. This highlights the significant impact that an at-fault accident can have on insurance premiums, with both types of coverage seeing notable increases.
| Average Yearly Minimum Coverage Premium | Average Yearly Full Coverage Premium | |
|---|---|---|
| Before an accident | $806 | $2,671 |
| After an at-fault accident | $1,175 | $3,841 |
| Difference | +46% | +44% |
These rates are estimates and can vary based on individual circumstances. For accurate pricing, it's recommended that you obtain personalized quotes.
Source: Bankrate
Last Updated: Nov 7th, 2025
HOW CAR INSURANCE RATES INCREASE AFTER AN ACCIDENT BY INSURANCE COMPANY
The table illustrates how average annual car insurance rates increase after an accident across various insurance companies. The rate increases range from $211 with Liberty Mutual to $927 with The General, showing a significant variation in how providers adjust premiums following an at-fault accident. USAA, State Farm, and GEICO have more moderate increases, ranging from $211 to $322, while companies like Progressive, Farmers, and Travelers see higher premium hikes, with increases ranging from $598 to $658. This highlights differences in how insurance providers respond to at-fault accidents, with some companies imposing larger premium increases than others.
| Insurance Provider | Average Annual Rate Increase After Accident |
|---|---|
| Liberty Mutual | $211 |
| USAA | $265 |
| State Farm | $267 |
| GEICO | $322 |
| Allstate | $370 |
| American Family | $489 |
| Nationwide | $552 |
| Travelers | $598 |
| Farmers | $647 |
| Progressive | $658 |
View More
These rates are estimates and can vary based on individual circumstances. For accurate pricing, it's recommended that you obtain personalized quotes.
Source: Insurify
Last Updated: Nov 7th, 2025
WHAT DISCOUNTS CAN I GET FOR CAR INSURANCE FOR ACCIDENT FORGIVENESS?
Accident forgiveness helps prevent insurance rates from rising after your first at-fault accident. Many insurers offer discounts to make coverage more affordable. Exploring such options helps reduce premiums while ensuring continued coverage. Here is a list of discounts available for interested policyholders:
Accident Forgiveness Discount
Safe Driver Discount
Multi-Policy Discount
Multi-Vehicle Discount
Loyalty Discount
Good Driver Discount
Low Mileage Discount
Bundling Discount
Pay-in-Full Discount
Defensive Driving Discount
WHAT ARE SOME TIPS FOR AFFORDABLE ACCIDENT FORGIVENESS?
Accident forgiveness can help drivers avoid premium increases after their first at-fault accident. To keep this valuable benefit affordable, it’s essential to understand how it works and explore options that align with your driving habits. Below are some helpful tips to help you get affordable options:
When shopping for car insurance with accident forgiveness, carefully compare quotes from multiple reputable insurance companies before settling on one.
Maintaining a clean driving record is very important for qualifying for accident forgiveness, as many insurers take a good driving record very seriously.
Consider bundling your car insurance with other policies, such as home or renters insurance, to significantly reduce your premium.
Always ask your insurance providers if there are any available discounts or special offers you may qualify for, so you don’t miss out on anything.
When selecting an insurance policy, evaluate your coverage limits and deductibles to ensure they align with your budget and needs.
GET A FREE ACCIDENT FORGIVENESS QUOTE
Looking to protect yourself from rate increases after an accident? Get a free quote today with CINCO Auto Insurance!
Simply submit the form, and once submitted, one of our friendly agents will reach out to discuss your personalized plan and address any questions you may have.
Prefer another method? Call, email, or visit us directly—we’re happy to help. Get your free quote from some of the leading insurers in town!
Car
Motorcycle
Commercial
Roadside Assistance
Other
FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS REGARDING ACCIDENT FORGIVENESS
AMERICA’S FAST GROWING INSURANCE
With over 7,000+ 5 star Google reviews and counting!
Vanessa Echeverry
I love Karina’s customer service. She is amazing—super friendly and super quick at getting you your insurance and on your way! She makes the entire process easy and is very helpful. Thank you, Karina!
Google Review
Walter P
I referred a few people here because of the exceptional job my rep provided. I call her my rep because she’s the only one I’ll go to from now on, and she’s the one I’ll refer my family to. I appreciate Paula for going above and beyond with me and the referrals I provided. All of this is due to the focus she placed on my situation. I will continue referring people to Paula for insurance solutions. Thank you again!
Google Review
Joyce Evans
Thank you, Javier, for the professional customer service. I am a senior citizen and don’t always get things right the first time. Thank you for your patience. I’m glad to have CINCO Insurance close to me in Garland on Northwest Highway.
Google Review
Doris Edmond
I spoke with Veronica, an agent with CINCO. She was the BEST! I was so stressed because I had been looking for coverage. Veronica took away all my stress. She worked with me tirelessly until she found auto coverage I could afford. I highly recommend her. She's professional, kind, courteous, and—most of all—patient. The definition of good customer service is VERONICA—my agent for life!
Google Review
Alva Ayuso
Valeria was very patient and courteous with us, answered all our questions, and helped us with all the paperwork! We will definitely recommend CINCO Auto Insurance to all our friends. Very satisfied!
Google Review
Rosalinda Alvarez
THANK YOU SO MUCH, AIME!! She offers outstanding customer service, going above and beyond to ensure a smooth and satisfying experience. Her professionalism, responsiveness, and attention to detail make every interaction pleasant and efficient. I highly recommend Aime 100% for her dedication to excellence and commitment to customer satisfaction! My family and I have found a great insurance company—all thanks to Aime.
Google Review
Alexus Monique
I’m currently looking for car insurance, and I’m so glad I decided to try this place out. The insurance agent Paula was very knowledgeable and sweet. She answered all my questions and made sure I didn’t leave with any doubts! I’m highly satisfied with my experience here and will be recommending this place. 😊
Google Review
Zouquayla Butler
I recently joined CINCO, and getting started was easy breezy. Javier is a 10/10—highly recommend! Great customer service, like we were old friends catching up while taking care of business. Thanks again, Javier. Awesome!
Google Review
Jose Santos
The service is excellent, and they help you with everything. You just have to be available, and they’ll do the work for you. I loved the work my agent Yolanda did. I recommend her—just ask for her!
Google Review
Rebecca Esquivel
Javier was awesome to talk to. He explained everything in detail and even repeated himself multiple times. Very, very patient with me—quick and ready to go! I was struggling to get a good quote, but he got me in and out. Thank you, Javier. 10/10 recommend!
Google Review
